|
Grading the Digital School: A Classroom Software Boom, but Mixed Results Despite the Hype
The pitch has sounded seductive to thousands of schools across the country for more than a decade. But a review by the United States Department of Education last year would suggest a much less alluring come-on: Undistinguished math curricula. Unproven results. The federal review of Carnegie Learning’s flagship software, Cognitive Tutor, said the program had “no discernible effects” on the standardized test scores of high school students. A separate 2009 federal look at 10 major software products for teaching algebra as well as elementary and middle school math and reading found that nine of them, including Cognitive Tutor, “did not have statistically significant effects on test scores.” Amid a classroom-based software boom estimated at 2.2 billion a year, debate continues to rage over the effectiveness of technology on learning and how best to measure it. But it is hard to tell that from technology companies’ promotional materials. Many companies ignore well-regarded independent studies that test their products’ effectiveness. Carnegie’s Web site, for example, makes no mention of the 2010 review, by the Education Department’s What Works Clearinghouse, which analyzed 24 studies of Cognitive Tutor’s effectiveness but found that only four of those met high research standards. Some firms misrepresent research by cherry-picking results and promote surveys or limited <a href="http://www.ecigs-store.com/egot-003-p-11.html"><strong>which electronic cigarette</strong></a> case studies that lack the scientific rigor required by the clearinghouse and other authorities. “The advertising from the companies is tremendous oversell compared to what they can actually demonstrate,” said Grover J. Whitehurst, a former director of the Institute of Education Sciences, the federal agency that includes What Works. School officials, confronted with a morass of complicated and sometimes conflicting research, often buy products based on personal impressions, marketing hype or faith in technology for its own sake. “They want the shiny new one,” said Peter Cohen, chief executive of Pearson School, a leading publisher of classroom texts and software. “They always want the latest, when other things have been proven the longest and demonstrated to get results.” Carnegie, one of the most respected of the educational software firms, is hardly <a href="http://www.ecigs-store.com/"><strong>e cigarette wholesale</strong></a> alone in overpromising or misleading. The Web site of Houghton Mifflin Harcourt says that “based on scientific research, Destination Reading is a powerful early literacy and adolescent literacy program,” but it fails to mention that it was one of the products the Department of Education found in 2009 not to have statistically significant effects on test scores. Similarly, Pearson’s Web site cites several studies of its own to support its claim that Waterford Early Learning improves literacy, without acknowledging the same 2009 study’s conclusion that it had little impact. And Intel, in a Web document urging schools to buy computers for every student, acknowledges that “there are no longitudinal, randomized trials linking eLearning to positive learning outcomes.” Yet it nonetheless argues that research shows that technology can lead to more engaged and economically successful students, happier teachers and more involved parents. “To compare this public relations analysis to a carefully constructed research study is laughable,” said Alex Molnar, professor of education at the National Education Policy Center at the University of Colorado. “They are selling their wares.” Carnegie officials say 600,000 students in 44 states use its products, many taking teacher-led classes three times a week with Carnegie-provided workbooks and spending the other two class periods in computer labs using Cognitive Tutor. The full curriculum can cost nearly <a href="http://www.ecigs-store.com/supertanker-001-p-22.html"><strong>cigarette prices</strong></a> three times as much as a typical textbook over six years. Officials declined to release annual revenue figures, but Carnegie Learning was acquired in August for 75 million by the parent of the for-profit University of Phoenix. Carnegie Mellon University, which had retained ownership of the Cognitive Tutor software and licensed it to Carnegie Learning, earned an additional 21.5 million from the sale. Steve Ritter, a founder and the chief scientist of Carnegie Learning, said there were flaws in the What Works Clearinghouse evaluations of Cognitive Tutor and disputed the Education Department’s judgment of what makes a worthy study. “What you want to focus on is more of the why,” he said, “and less of a horse race to find out what works and doesn’t.” A Carnegie spokeswoman, Mary Murrin, said in a statement that the company used “the data from all studies with varying outcomes to continuously improve our programs.” Karen Billings, a vice president of the Software and Information Industry Association — a trade group representing many education companies — said the problem was not that companies overpromise, but that schools often do not properly deploy the products or train teachers to use them. Ms. Billings’s group helped design the field trials, in 132 schools, for the landmark 2009 government study of 10 software products, which was ordered by Congress and cost 15 million.
|
buy azithromycin no prescription nedeed fast shipping zithromax tri pack
buy azithromycin online cost of zithromax
buy azithromycin without prescription - buy azithromycin in usa where can i buy zithromax 500mg in uk zithromax dosage pediatric |
where can i buy zithromax 500mg in uk zithromax pediatric dose
where can i buy azithromycin antibiotic in uk zithromax half life
buy online zithromax 250mg azithromycin - buy zithromax 250mg without prescription buy azithromycin no prescription nedeed zithromax |
buy zithromax 500mg in usa zithromax contraindications
where to buy azithromycin antibiotic zithromax ear infection
where to buy zithromax 250mg - buy azithromycin online buy online azithromycin zithromax alcohol |
Msm Sulfur Pills
Procrit Cancer Drug purchase buspar If the medication is stopped suddenly it can cause a withdrawal syndrome that can be very uncomfortable and even cause further health problems. http://superiorsilverco.com/ - buspar for sale
|
Cortex Drug Manufacturer
Emergency Activated Charcoal Tablets cheap buspar online Buspar is like a lot of medications in that it cannot be stopped abruptly, so patients need to tell their doctor they would like to stop taking it so that they can be weaned off of it slowly and safely. http://superiorsilverco.com/ - buy cheap buspar
|
where to buy azithromycin zithromax 250mg zithromax order
buy online zithromax 500mg zithromax for cats
buy azithromycin in usa online - buy azithromycin without prescription where can i buy azithromycin in uk zithromax doses |
рецептом против выпадениями волос mival
Добро пожаловать!
КАКАЯ ПРИЧЕСКА ТЕБЕ ПОДОЙДЕТ?   СКАЧАТЬ - Плакали после последнего визита к парикмахеру? - Теперь вы носите прическу в стиле 80-х, а в парикмахерскую отправлялись, чтобы подравнять длинные кончики? - Вам интересно, почему парикмахер или косметолог не выказывает особой радости при вашем появлении? Не беспокойтесь – кто хотя бы однажды не приходил в отчаяние? Мы предлагаем Вам подобрать себе макияж и прическу онлайн - это очень просто. Поэтому, перед тем, как в следующий раз записаться к парикмахеру, визажисту или косметологу, внимательно ознакомьтесь с предложенными вариантами по изменению Вашего внешнего вида. Разработанные программные продукты работают онлайн благодаря Интернет. Вам только нужно под рукой держать свое фото в электронном виде и проблема подбора косметики и прически решается в считанные минуты. В общем я - в восторге, с самого утра играюсь... Воспользуйтесь предложенными ссылками для перехода к любимому занятию. Описание программы на других форумах: профессиональная краска для волос луо колор продажа Програмный комплекс можно найти используя следующие ключевые слова минусы наращивания волос форум свадебные прически для коротких волос в тюмени плюсы и минусы филировки волос виртуальный парикмахер прически и стрижки как сделать прическу на длинные волосы описание новой модели unit электрощипцы-стайлер для волос ucb-313 свадебная прическа распущенные волосы ламинирование волос лореаль в каком салоне красноярска сделать выпрямление волос волоса группа уклaдкa тонких волос бигуди стрижки для мелированых волос фото падение волос. маски для волос и кожи головы, народные рецепты хорошее средство против секущихся волос расчески для волос с антистатическим процесс наращивания волос реферат прически и одежда в стиле 60х годов кто делал ламинирование волос проблемы с волосами, на затылке лысина к какому врачу обратиться почему курчавые волосы склонны к сухости краска для волос лореаль цветовая гама как правильно сделать прическу с начесом горящий в черных волосах фосфор разъедающий локти до мужчины любят красные волосы серые глаза, смуглый цвет лица-какой цвет волос подойдет с чем связана повышенная волосатость у девушек фото домашних причесок на длинные волосы краска дляя волос лореаль с тройной защитой вростание волос после эпиляции бикини просмотреть книгу прически с заколками окантовка в стрижке когда можно подстрич волосы по гороскопу человека праздничая вечерняя прическа для длинных волос как правильно высушить волосы крупным планом волосатые пилотки краска для волос палетте дэлюкс этапы ламинирования волос в домашних условиях |
| All times are GMT. The time now is 11:58 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Free Advertising Forums | Free Advertising Message Boards | Post Free Ads Forum