Yanta District Court Model Option of any evidence that the Huayi Brothers and placement of an advertisement, making any financial or other responsibilities of the association, the contractor can not be held responsible Huayi Brothers filed for Model Option established.
CHEN Xiao-Mei said that she July 22 tickets in Xi'an Bona Studios and watch movies August 12, she again went to Boehner Studios with friends watching the film, arrived on time, she was no choice but to watch the first ten minutes of ads. h Xiao-Mei Chen said: Bona and Huayi Brothers Studios in the absence of any informed, express case, bundled advertising and film, screening, violating the consumer's right to know. In addition, in cinemas this relatively closed environment, consumers have no choice but to watch advertisements violated the right of consumer choice. Xiao-Mei Chen sue the two defendants returned to 35 per movie ticket and pay 1 yuan for mental damages and a public apology on national media.
court that day, Boehner Studios The very fact that Beijing head office manager of the Ministry of Justice,
tods outlet, Huayi Brothers, said lawyer Wang, Xiao-Mei Chen ticket and watched the movie, did not cause any actual loss to the Model Option. However,
Tods shoes, for the plaintiff because the Studios Bona watch the movie
Huayi Brothers side view, CHEN Xiao-Mei as consumers go to the movies before, and cinema entertainment services to form a contractual relationship exists between Huayi Brothers Model Option and any form of contractual relationship, so she has no right claim any right to the Huayi Brothers.
Yanta District Court that,
tods, according to SARFT issued advertisements on the strengthening of the relevant provisions of video patch, patch Bona Studios equipped with their own ads, but not before showing appropriate and timely performance of this obligations, resulting in the plaintiff was forced to watch up to 12 minutes of placement ads. Studios behavior not only constitutes a breach of contract, also in line with the elements of infringement. Therefore, the court found Studios Bona Xiao-Mei Chen, ticket refund 35 per section. At the same time, the court rejected other claims Xiao-Mei Chen.